Ir al contenido 
When it comes to CNC processes, selecting the appropriate machining method can significantly impact your project’s cost, quality, and turnaround time. One of the most common comparisons in modern manufacturing is CNC milling vs CNC turning. Both are considered CNC machining, but their methods, best uses, and the things they make vary greatly.
In this article, we’ll explore the turning vs milling operations, analyze the machinability of materials, discuss tolerances in CNC machining, and evaluate the CNC machining cost factors to help you make an informed decision.
A Brief Introduction to CNC Machining
A CNC machine (Computer Numerical Control) takes away material from a workpiece using computerized tools. Many different industries, such as aerospace and medical devices, rely on CNC for its accuracy, speed, and ability to repeat tasks.
The two most popular machining techniques are CNC milling and CNC turning.
CNC Milling vs CNC Turning: An Overview
| Feature | CNC Milling | CNC Turning |
| Material Movement | Stationary workpiece, rotating tool | Rotating workpiece, stationary tool |
| Ideal Geometry | Complex 3D shapes, slots, and holes | Cylindrical or round parts |
| Machine Axis | Typically 3-5 axes | Typically 2 axes |
| Setup Time | Higher setup time | Lower setup time |
| Part Precision | High for complex geometries | Very high for round parts |
| Common Materials | Metals, plastics, and composites | Metals, some plastics |
The difference between CNC milling and turning primarily lies in the movement of the tool and the workpiece. Milling uses a rotating cutting tool at a stationary part, whereas turning turns a stationary part against a fixed cutting tool.
CNC Milling for Complex Designs
The multi-point cutting tool of CNC milling moves across and around the material to form the proper shape. It stands out for developing complex and irregular shapes.
Benefits of CNC Milling
- Perfect for sculpting objects and shapes in three dimensions
- Can add multiple parts such as holes, slots, and pockets.
- Multiaxis machines produce finished surfaces that are very smooth and uniform.
Applications
- Aerospace brackets
- Mold components
- Assemblies that are built of many different mechanical elements
CNC Turning – Best for Cylindrical Parts
CNC turning works best for producing parts that have symmetry when they are rotated. The wood piece is attached to a chuck, spun, and then a single-point tool is used to scrape off parts of the block.
Advantages of using CNC Turning
- Specific processes that handle smaller chunks of time for cylindrical parts
- More accuracy in concentric parts
- It is cheaper for large or frequent orders.
Applications
- Shafts and bushings are components that you will find in the drivetrain.
- The trailers have housings and couplings.
- Threaded parts
Choosing Between CNC Turning and Milling
When choosing between CNC turning and milling, several factors come into play:
- What is the shape of the part: cylindrical? Use turns to get around the track. Is the shape one that is 3D and not flat?
- Milling is used for complex parts produced in small quantities, and turning is for high-quantity, simple parts.
- Surface finish and tolerances: Both offer tight tolerances in CNC machining, but the ideal choice depends on the specific geometry.
Tolerances in CNC Machining
Tolerances in CNC machining refer to how close the produced part is to the specified dimensions. Many tolerances are used:
- The standard tolerance for a process is explained here.
- The tolerance for CNC Milling is within ± 0.005 in (0.13 mm).
- The accuracy of CNC Turning is ± 0.002 in (0.05 mm).
When tolerances are very close, machines slow down and more inspection is needed, which leads to greater expenses.
Machinability of Materials
Machinability of materials is a critical factor in choosing a CNC process. For example:
- Aluminum: The process of milling and turning is very suitable for it.
- Stainless Steel: It is harder than most; it makes tools wear faster, and it needs to be round for best results in turning.
- Titanium: It is not easy to machine, but titanium can be shaped with the right machinery.
CNC Machining Cost Factors
The CNC machining cost factors vary depending on:
- Cost difference (titanium is more costly than aluminum).
- Geometry is very complex.
- Required tolerances
- Setting up the machines involves checking how worn the tools are.
Generally, manual vs automated machining also plays a role. Setting tasks up manually is cheaper for fewer orders, but more than a few orders benefit from automation.
Manual vs Automated Machining
While traditional methods like manual lathes and mills are still in use, manual vs automated machining debates often focus on:
- Labor cost: If work is done by hand, there will be more people, but if it’s automated, you should budget for more money at the start.
- Accuracy: With CNC automation, work is finished with more accurate results.
- Consistency: Automation gives more consistent results than a person.
- Reliability: Because CNC is more efficient and reliable, it is used in modern manufacturing.
CNC Milling vs CNC Turning – Which Should You Choose?
The choice between CNC milling vs CNC turning depends on the specific requirements of your project:
- Run CNC turning on items that require even sides and are needed in high quantities.
- Choose CNC milling if you need to make parts with complicated shapes, smooth finishes, and multiple-axis features.
Understanding the difference between CNC milling and turning helps optimize your production process, improve product quality, and control costs.
Final Thoughts
Understanding turning vs milling operations allows you to optimize part design, reduce lead times, and choose the right machining techniques for your application. Whether you’re designing a custom automotive part or mass-producing mechanical shafts, knowing when to use CNC milling vs CNC turning can drastically improve your project’s efficiency and outcome.
FAQs
What’s the main difference between CNC milling and turning?
The main difference between CNC milling and turning is the movement: in milling, the tool moves, and in turning, the workpiece rotates.
Which one gives a better result: milling or turning?
CNC turning is best for creating round parts, and CNC milling is good for detailed shapes.
Are there cost differences between CNC milling vs CNC turning?
Yes. Taking less time, CNC turning is often a low-cost option for cylindrical parts. Complex designs in CNC milling may be pricier.
Which materials should be used for CNC machining?
High machinability, which belongs to aluminum and brass, is the best property you can find. Titanium and similar hard metals need special tools to work with them.
Are CNC machines capable of making parts with very small variations?
If the component material and toolpath are right, CNC milling and turning machines are capable of achieving ±0.002-inch tolerances.
